Supreme Court of Texas Blog

Recent Denials and Dismissals

 

These cases have been denied review by the Court. No motion for rehearing is currently pending.

Docket Case Name Decision Date
23-1004 PATRICIA MONZINGO, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF W.J. M., A MINOR, AND MADISON MONZINGO v. JOHN WOODROW FLORIES 2024-03-01
24-0126 T.M. v. TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES 2024-03-01
24-0059 IN RE RALPH OYETOLA OYELAHAN AND TIFFANY MONIQUE OYELAHAN 2024-03-01
24-0001 NORA SALADO, JESUS MARTINEZ, BERTHA PEDREGON, ELSINA AVALOS, NATY RUBALCAVA, RAMON TIRRES, OFELIA MALTOS, ROSA SERNA, LUZ ELENA ABASTA, HERIBERTO ABASTA, PORFIRIO ROJAS, JOSEFINA SALAZAR, PARISHIONERS OF SAN JOSE CATHOLIC CHURCH v. ROMAN CATHOLIC DIOCESE OF EL PASO, MARK J. SEITZ, BISHOP OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC DIOCESE OF EL PASO 2024-03-01
23-0838 DIANA INGRID REISMAN SEXTON v. FORT BEND COUNTY; BAILIFF JOSE FALCON; DEPUTY SHERIFF GABRIEL CARDENAS, DEPUTY SHERIFF CONNOR GREEN, DEPUTY SHERIFF ROSS, DEPUTY SHERIFF COX, ET AL. 2024-03-01
24-0115 IN THE INTEREST OF A.H. AND K.H., CHILDREN 2024-03-01
23-1042 ROBERT G. WALKER v. LAMAR COUNTY, ET AL. 2024-03-01
23-0958 DR. JOHN SZABUNIEWICZ v. KING INVESTMENTS, LTD., PHILLIP KING, AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF THE EARL KING, DECEASED AND PHILLIP S. KING 2024-03-01
23-1047 IN THE MATTER OF THE MARRIAGE OF AMANDA CARTER AND PHILIP CARTER AND IN THE INTEREST OF K.C. AND K.C., CHILDREN 2024-03-01
24-0032 TOMMY LYNN COOPER v. SUSAN CAROL BOLSTER 2024-03-01
23-1009 ONCO FILTRATION, INC. v. PEDESTAL SVN INVESTMENTS, LLC 2024-03-01
24-0144 IN RE ROLANDO SAENZ 2024-02-27
24-0133 IN RE ROY J. ELIZONDO III 2024-02-26
23-0981 IN THE INTEREST OF S.S.B. AND A.A.C., CHILDREN 2024-02-23
24-0056 IN RE CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY 2024-02-23
24-0057 IN RE MOHAMED LAHAM 2024-02-23
23-0836 HASSELL CONSTRUCTION CO. INC., DERIVATIVELY BY AND THROUGH ITS SHAREHOLDER, ROYCE HASSELL ; R. HASSELL & COMPANY, INC., AND R. HASSELL BUILDERS, INC. v. SPRINGWOODS REALTY COMPANY, SPRINGWOODS REALTY, INC., HARRIS COUNTY IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT #18, WALTER P. MOORE & ASSOCIATES, INC., D/B/A WALTER P. MOORE AND COSTELLO, INC. 2024-02-23
23-1032 IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF ROBBIE CHRIS BRISTOW, DECEASED 2024-02-23
23-0806 KOFFEY SMITH EL-BEY v. THE ESTATE OF ROBERT C. WILLIAMS, DECEASED AND PEGGY RUTH WILLIAMS AS INDEPENDENT EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT C. WILLIAMS 2024-02-23
23-0805 KOFFEY SMITH EL-BEY v. THE ESTATE OF ROBERT C. WILLIAMS, DECEASED AND PEGGY RUTH WILLIAMS AS INDEPENDENT EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF ROBERT C. WILLIAMS 2024-02-23
24-0066 IN THE INTEREST OF R.C., A CHILD 2024-02-23
24-0008 IN RE ANTONIO MAURICE LACY 2024-02-23
23-0730 IN THE INTEREST OF V.J. AND V.J., CHILDREN 2024-02-16
22-0425 NATHAN D. ALBERT AND CHISHOLM TRAIL REDI-MIX, LLC v. FORT WORTH & WESTERN RAILROAD COMPANY, DAVOIL, INC AND WILLIAM S. DAVIS 2024-02-16
23-0989 IN THE INTEREST OF H.A.L. AND T.A.H., CHILDREN 2024-02-16
23-1008 PAUL JOHNSON v. BASTROP CENTRAL APPRAISAL DISTRICT 2024-02-16
23-1019 TEXAS REIT, LLC, ALI CHOUDHRI, DALIO HOLDINGS I, LLC AND DALIO HOLDINGS II, LLC v. MOKARAM-LATIF WEST LOOP, LTD AND ALI MOKARAM 2024-02-16
23-0518 IN RE ROBERT GANDY 2024-02-16
23-0746 WELLNESS AND AESTHETICS INSTITUTE, PA AND THE ESTATE OF CONSTANTINE KOTSANIS v. JB&B CAPITAL, LLC 2024-02-16
23-0559 NAVIGATOR OIL & MINERALS, INC.; WARRIOR EXPLORATION, LLC; PATRICK BANAISE BLAKE; MITCHELL C. MEYERS; MICHAEL J. DANIEL; SPENCER EVANS BLAKE; RILEY BLAKE LEADER; AND PATRICIA DALBY MATTHIES v. VAN MARTIN GASKINS, TRUSTEE OF THE VAN MARTIN GASKINS FAMILY TRUST; KELLY JOE GASKINS, TRUSTEE OF THE KELLY JOE GASKINS FAMILY TRUST; KAYLA GASKINS MCDONNELL, TRUSTEE OF THE KAYLA GASKINS MCDONNELL FAMILY TRUST 2024-02-16
24-0034 IN RE STEVEN MICHAEL BACKSTROM 2024-02-16
23-0781 IN RE RANDALL KUBOSH 2024-02-16
23-0816 IN THE INTEREST OF J.P.H., ET AL. 2024-02-16
22-0713 CENTRAL MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. RELIANCE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC. 2024-02-16
24-0004 IN THE INTEREST OF S.T.S. 2024-02-16
23-0844 EAGLE RAILCAR SERVICES, L.P., EAGLE RAILCAR SERVICES - ROSCOE, INC., EAGLE RAILCAR SERVICES - CAIRO, OHIO, LLC AND EAGLE RAILCAR SERVICES - WICHITA FALLS, TEXAS, LLC v. MATHESON TRI-GAS, INC. 2024-02-16
23-0490 BRENT SOLOWAY AND ANNA LIU SOLOWAY v. THE IRELAND FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, A TEXAS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 2024-02-16
23-0869 IN RE MUSTARD SEED CONSTRUCTION, LLC 2024-02-16
23-0884 TYRA COBB, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF N.F., A MINOR, AND QUENTIN PRINCE v. ALNA PROPERTIES II, LLC 2024-02-16
23-0654 2017 YALE DEVELOPMENT, LLC v. STEADFAST FUNDING, LLC, ET. AL. 2024-02-16
24-0095 IN THE INTEREST OF J.J.S., JR., K.W. AND R.G., CHILDREN 2024-02-16
23-0691 IN THE MATTER OF THE MARGARET M. MARQUART AND DAVID D. MARQUART TRUST 2024-02-16
23-0422 WILLIAM KORIOTH; WTK DEVELOPMENT, LLC; KONA COAST LLC; GUADALUPE 306, LP; AND GUADALUPE 306 GP, LLC v. WHITEWATER INVESTMENT PARTNERS, LLC; OXBOW LAND PARTNERS, LLC; HIDEOUT ON THE HORSESHOE, LLC; WHITEWATER SPORTS, LLC; AND KONA COAST VENTURE, LTD 2024-02-16
23-0928 BARRETT HORTON v. MMM VENTURES LLC, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS GENERAL PARTNER OF CRESCENT ESTATES CUSTOM HOMES LP, AND CRESCENT ESTATES CUSTOM HOMES LP 2024-02-16
23-0929 CHERYL ANNE HUGHES, AS TRUSTEE OF THE JIMMY CELTYN HUGHES QTIP MARITAL TRUST v. JENNIFER C. CASS AND NICHOLE R. MALICOAT 2024-02-16
23-0941 IN THE INTEREST OF A.H.S. AND A.Y.S., CHILDREN 2024-02-16
23-0713 LOUIS ROSALES, SR. v. ALLSTATE VEHICLE AND PROPERTY INSURANCE COMPANY 2024-02-16
23-0892 GARY BRUCE PEEK v. LINDA MAYFIELD 2024-02-09
23-0903 IN THE MATTER OF THE RUFF MANAGEMENT TRUST 2024-02-09
24-0103 IN RE JACOB CORRELL, TIMOTHY KEIDEL, AND KCM EXTERIORS, LLC 2024-02-09
23-0998 RAYMOND LUNA v. ROSARIO GARCIA 2024-02-09
23-0948 MICHAEL BEAL v. PRUVIT VENTURES, INC. 2024-02-09
23-0969 JAMES W. THOMPSON, JAMIE L. THOMPSON, AND RUBICON COMMUNICATIONS, LLC D/B/A NETGATE v. CHRISTOPHER M. BUECHLER, INDIVIDUALLY AND DERIVATIVELY ON BEHALF OF NOMINAL DEFENDANT ELECTRIC SHEEP FENCING LLC 2024-02-09
24-0003 DAVID STROIK v. NATALIE STROIK 2024-02-09
24-0096 IN RE TAKASHA FRANCIS 2024-02-09
23-1037 CHARLES & DONNA ROSS, STEPHEN BROWN, DOUG BUTLER, JEP & JUDY CANON, PETE CARLSSON, TERESA & JOE COLDEWEY, JESSICA CURRY, ANGELA EATON, RONNY & STEPHANIE FIKES, JOHN & MARGARET GALLAGHER, GARY & MARY GRIFFIN, CHASE JAMES, MIKE KELLEY, JOHN LAMAESTRA, NUNZIO & MARCELLA LAMAESTRA, ED LONG, PATRICK MCNAMARA, JULES MORRIS, LAWRENCE NEIL, ANDREA & DENIS PANTEL, MIKE SAENZ, JOHN SCONIERS, v. MATTHEW MARSENISON 2024-02-09
24-0094 IN RE MOSAIC BAYBROOK ONE, LP, MOSAIC BAYBROOK TWO, LP, AND MOSAIC RESIDENTIAL, INC. 2024-02-06
24-0089 IN RE JASMINE JARBIS 2024-02-05
23-1024 TEXAS POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS JOINT SELF-INSURANCE FUND v. TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE - DIVISION OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION AND COMMISSIONER CASSIE BROWN IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY 2024-02-02
23-0790 RICHARD D. DAVIS L.L.P., A NEVADA LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP, AND RICHARD D. DAVIS, L.L.P., A TEXAS GENERAL PARTNERSHIP v. ANDY KNOTT, BILL GREEN, DEMPSEY GEAREN, JIM PHILLIPS, PHIL BIRKELBACH, PAUL KATES, DANNY LANGHORNE, HANS VAN DER VOORT, GENE MORTON, AND STANLEY HOFFPAUIR 2024-02-02
24-0014 IN RE THE CITY OF SAN ANTONIO AND RODERICK SANCHEZ 2024-02-02
23-0952 IN THE INTEREST OF A.M., A CHILD 2024-02-02
23-1030 IN THE MATTER OF K.J. 2024-02-02
24-0079 JONI DODD v. MONA WOOTEN, ET AL. 2024-02-02
23-0914 IN RE CLAYTON P. NICKLAS 2024-02-02
24-0063 IN RE CITY OF RANGER, TEXAS 2024-02-01
24-0033 IN RE MOSAIC BAYBROOK ONE, L.P. AND MOSAIC BAYBROOK TWO, L.P., AND MOSAIC RESIDENTIAL, INC. 2024-01-30
24-0062 IN RE DARRYL HEFFNER 2024-01-29
23-0171 ABDERRAHIM ENNADI v. SOPHIE ANDREE CHRISTINE ENNADI 2024-01-26
23-0557 EAGLE ROCK TIMBER, INC. v. ROCK HARD RENTAL, LLC AND SOLID ROCK CRUSHING, LLC 2024-01-26
22-0400 TEXAS COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY v. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY, JESSE L. MYROW, AND WESLEY R. MYROW 2024-01-26
22-0746 JOLIE CHU v. WINDERMERE LAKES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. 2024-01-26
23-0683 BARRETT FIREARMS MANUFACTURING, INC., BARRETT FIREARMS USA, INC., AND FEDERAL CARTRIDGE COMPANY v. XAVIER FLORES 2024-01-26
23-0732 STATE OF TEXAS v. L.S.L.H. 2024-01-26
23-0759 DENISE MCDONALD AND DIANA DOBBINS v. JACY GATES 2024-01-26
23-0771 COTTONWOOD TRAIL INVESTMENTS, LLC v. PIRATES PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION 2024-01-26
23-0770 CHARLES CAUTHORN v. PIRATES PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION 2024-01-26
22-1013 MONTGOMERY J. BENNETT AND DALLAS EXPRESS MEDIA, INC. D/B/A THE DALLAS EXPRESS v. STEVEN MONACELLI AND THE DALLAS WEEKLY, INC. 2024-01-26
22-1018 SM ENERGY COMPANY v. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY 2024-01-26
22-1063 LUIS R. VARELA v. CITY OF EL PASO 2024-01-26
23-0013 IN RE RLB CONTRACTING, INC. 2024-01-26
23-0217 EMILY FOURNIER, DAVID FOURNIER, THOMAS NELMS, AND SUSAN NELMS v. ANGELWYLDE HOA, INC. AND ANGELWYLDE PLACE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. 2024-01-26
23-0888 IN THE INTEREST OF B.U., A CHILD 2024-01-26
23-0301 CHRIS KILBOURNE v. OVINTIV EXPLORATION, INC. 2024-01-26
23-0335 MANISCH SOHANI AND ANIS VIRANI v. NIZAR SUNESARA 2024-01-26
23-0336 ENVEN ENERGY CORPORATION AND ENVEN ENERGY VENTURES, LLC v. DAVID M. DUNWOODY, JR. 2024-01-26
23-0896 MATTHEW BROWN v. WILLIAM EDMONDS AND PAMELA EDMONDS, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NEXT FRIEND ON BEHALF OF A.B., C.B., AND M.B. 2024-01-26
23-0893 AUSTIN JSB, LTD. v. OTWELL REALTY, LTD. 2024-01-26
23-0902 MAGDALENA FLORES v. CRYSTAL CITY INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 2024-01-26
23-0399 IN THE INTEREST OF E.G.P. 2024-01-26
23-0395 KEVIN DALE DIDWAY AND WILLIAM MARK DIDWAY v. JAMES GRIFFIS 2024-01-26
23-0445 CLAYMORE HOLDINGS, LLC v. CREDIT SUISSE AG, CAYMAN ISLANDS BRANCH AND CREDIT SUISSE (USA) LLC 2024-01-26
22-0914 NETFLIX, INC.; NETFLIX WORLDWIDE ENTERTAINMENT, LLC; KYOKO MIYAKE; SARIT G. WORK; SAMANTHA KNOWLES; KATE GILL; JIGSAW PRODUCTIONS, LLC; MUDDY WATERS PRODUCTIONS LLC; ALEX GIBNEY; PHILIP ROSS; JO ANN RIVERA; LAURA A. MARTINEZ; BRITTANY A. MARTINEZ; MICHELLE C. MARTINEZ; AND JOSE H. MARTINEZ, v. TONYA BARINA 2024-01-26
23-0949 TITE WATER ENERGY, LLC v. WILD WILLY'S WELDING, LLC 2024-01-26
23-0947 EUGENIA WOODARD v. TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE, DIVISION OF WORKERS COMPENSATION; CAPP ELECTRIC COMPANY; AND TEXAS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 2024-01-26
23-0939 IN RE THE LANDING AT BLANCO PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION 2024-01-26
23-0983 IN RE RYAN, LLC 2024-01-26
23-0991 STEVEN M. DUNBAR v. CITY OF HOUSTON 2024-01-26
23-1012 IN RE RODOLFO G. ROSA 2024-01-26
23-1021 TIFFANY LONG AND ALL OCCUPANTS v. PARATHEKE ENTERPRISES, LLC 2024-01-26
23-0232 IN RE PUBLICACIONES E. IMPRESOS DEL NORTE, S. DE R.L. DE C.V., PUBLICACIONES PASO DEL NORTE, S.A. DE C.V., AND PASO DEL NORTE PUBLISHING, INC. 2024-01-26
23-1041 IN THE INTEREST OF L.W., A CHILD 2024-01-26
24-0031 IN THE INTEREST OF A.E., P.E., AND Q.S. A/K/A Q.S., JR., CHILDREN 2024-01-26
24-0035 IN RE DAVID DILLARD 2024-01-26
23-1007 KIMBERLY GOESLING v. AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC. 2024-01-19
23-0793 DONALD W. TAYLOR v. CLARK ASPY, MADISON PRESTON AND NAMAN HOWELL SMITH & LEE, PLLC 2024-01-12
23-0615 KENNETH D. MCKEOUGH v. CAMELOT TOWNHOMES ASSOCIATION, INC. 2023-12-15
23-0231 PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS v. LUMINANT ENERGY COMPANY LLC 2023-12-01
23-0406 WES GILBREATH, JR., STACEY GILBREATH POWELL, ELLIOT GILBREATH, AND MARK RITTER; SIGNAD, LTD., SIGNAD GP, LLC, BEN NEVIS WEST, LTD., CULCREUCH WEST, LLC, BIG SIGNS & LEASING #1, LTD., BIG SIGNS & LEASING #2, LTD., BIG SIGNS & LEASING #3, LTD., BIG SIGNS & LEASING #4, LTD., BIG SIGNS & LEASING #5, LTD., AND BIG SIGNS & LEASING #6, LTD., BIG EASTEX #1, LTD., REALTY ACQUISITIONS & HOLDINGS, LLC, AND BIG LEASING, LLC v. LISA R. GILBREATH HORAN, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE LISA GILBREATH HORAN 2001 IRREVOCABLE TRUST 2023-10-13
22-0394 IN RE UNITY NATIONAL BANK 2023-06-16
23-0105 IN THE INTEREST OF M.S.M., K.C.M., AND C.C.M. 2023-04-21
22-0754 TERRY FISHER, 829 YALE ST., LLC, AND ASSURANCE HOME WARRANTY GROUP, LLC v. STEADFAST FUNDING LLC, ET AL. 2023-01-27
21-0927 EAST TEXAS EDUCATIONAL INSURANCE ASSOCIATION v. MARIA D. RAMIREZ 2022-06-03
21-0943 KATHY JONES-HOSPOD v. NIKKI G. MAPLES, INDIVIDUALLY, AND THE LAW OFFICE OF NIKKI G. MAPLES, PLLC 2022-05-06
21-1036 VIVIAN ALFORD v. BARBARA STROLL 2022-02-18
21-0045 TEXAS WINDSTORM INSURANCE ASSOCIATION v. BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB OF THE COASTAL BEND, INC. 2021-12-17
21-0506 RICH ROBINS v. AUSTEN PERRY CLINKENBEARD AND JONATHON G. CLINKENBEARD A/K/A JON CLINKENBEARD 2021-12-03
21-0786 IN THE INTEREST OF I.E. AND M.E., CHILDREN 2021-11-19
20-0574 GOLIAD COUNTY, TEXAS v. EUGENE CALVIN BONNET 2021-11-19
21-0231 DENNIS FULLER AND LUCIE LAFRENIERE v. RONY-CLAUDE LE BRUN AND EQUINOX DESIGN, INC. 2021-09-24
21-0019 QUINCY DESHAN BUTLER v. BRYAN COLLIER, GREGORY VAUGHN, KEVIN WHEAT, CAPT. CURRY, KIMBERLY STRIBLIN, C. BAKER, TRAY HUTTO, OFFICER PITONES, TERI HALL, SGT. MIKE BROWN AND NETRA HICKS 2021-08-27
20-0532 TEXAS CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL AND BAYLOR COLLEGE OF MEDICINE v. SHERRY KNIGHT, KENNY KNIGHT INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NEXT FRIENDS OF KAMDYN KNIGHT 2021-06-11
20-0460 JOSEPH ANDREW BEACH v. CHRISTINE NICOLE BEACH 2021-05-07
21-0189 BILLY WAYNE LEWIS v. COUNTY OF MILAM 2021-04-30
19-0238 CATHAY BANK v. LYDA SWINERTON BUILDERS, INC. 2021-03-05
21-0001 IN RE STATE OF TEXAS 2021-01-01
20-0534 JALARAM GURU, LLC AND DUMAS MANAGEMENT, LLC v. INSIGNIA HOSPITALITY GROUP, INC. 2020-12-11
20-0385 WINNIE STACEY ALWAZZAN v. ISA ALI ALWAZZAN AND INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES CO., LTD. 2020-11-13
20-0279 ZIAUNNISA K. LODHI v. SHAH A. HAQUE 2020-09-11
20-0540 1812 FRANKLIN STREET, BONHAM, TEXAS, ET AL. v. THE STATE OF TEXAS 2020-09-04
20-0069 CHRISTOPHER MITCHELL AND TIFFANY MITCHELL v. CALVIN PRESTON 2020-06-05
19-0917 IN THE INTEREST OF A.L.P. A CHILD 2020-06-05
19-0881 TAMISHA NICOLE CAMPBELL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS GUARDIAN AND NEXT FRIEND OF TAMATHA NANETTE WILLIAMS, AN INCAPACITATED PERSON v. PAUL H. POMPA, M.D. AND MARCUS LESLY WEATHERALL, M.D. 2020-04-03
20-0036 ROSA LINDA SANCHEZ GAULT v. WILLIAM GAULT 2020-03-27
19-0723 PANHANDLE STEEL ERECTORS, INC. v. LUIS CANTU 2020-03-13
19-0834 EX PARTE M.T. 2020-02-14
19-0645 IN THE INTEREST OF S.C., A CHILD 2019-11-15
18-0427 LINDA MOODY v. EDNA M. ARCHER, HADEN BEARDSLEY AND SARAH KATHRYN PACHECO 2019-10-04
19-0128 THE STATE OF TEXAS BY AND THROUGH THE CITY OF DALLAS v. DALLAS PETS ALIVE 2019-07-26
19-0109 IN THE INTEREST OF G.V.S., ET AL., CHILDREN 2019-03-22
18-0057 LEE WEBESTER v. GSE LINING TECHNOLOGY LLC 2018-06-15
17-0601 IN THE INTEREST OF R.P., JR., G.P., M.P., AND R.M.A.P., MINOR CHILDREN 2017-09-15
17-0407 CHARLES M. WILSON, III AND GORANSON BAIN, PLLC v. SHAMOUN & NORMAN, LLP 2017-07-28
16-1000 ESTATE OF WILLIAM HENRY MATTHEWS, III, DECEASED 2017-03-31
16-0894 JOHN THOMAS AIKEN v. ANGELIQUE S. NAYLOR 2017-01-13
16-0852 TRENT STEVEN GRIFFIN v. AMERICAN ZURICH INSURANCE COMPANY 2017-01-13
16-0394 IN THE INTEREST OF K.O., A.O., AND O.O., CHILDREN 2016-12-16