Supreme Court of Texas Blog

No. 20-0707
Click for Official Page

THIM T. NGUYEN, ET AL. v. MIKAL C WATTS, ET AL.

A petition was filed on September 11, 2020. No response has yet been requested or filed.

No Opinions Yet

The Court has not issued any opinions in this case.

 

Court of Appeals

Appellate District:1st Court of Appeals
Outcome Below:Aff/Pt and Rev & Rem/Pt
COA Docket No.:01-18-00421-CV
Opinion Author:Honorable Richard F. Hightower

Trial Court

Trial Court:55th District Court
County:Harris
Trial Judge:Honorable Jeffrey A. Shadwick
Trial Docket:2016-13749

Entries on SCOTX Orders Lists

None yet

Docket Entries

Date Event Outcome  
2020-09-22 Case forwarded to Court
2020-09-15 Response Waiver filed  
2020-09-14 Response Waiver filed  
2020-09-11 Court reporter/recorder's record
2020-09-11 Supplement to Clerk's/Reporter's Record
2020-09-11 Clerk's Record
2020-09-11 Petition for Review (Petitioner)  

Parties

Party Counsel Role
Tom Phan
 
Petitioner
Lieu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung PhuongThi Tran
 
Petitioner
Ha Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Huong Hoai Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phung Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
David Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tony Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Minh Tan Vo
 
Petitioner
Chau Ho Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Si Van Pham
 
Petitioner
Lai Le
 
Petitioner
Khai Pham
 
Petitioner
Thanh-Huong Thi Hoang
 
Petitioner
Chau Minh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
George Lai Lu
 
Petitioner
Thu HanhThi Huynh
 
Petitioner
Kim-Anh Thi Vu
 
Petitioner
Thanh Cao Huynh
 
Petitioner
Chau Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Khanh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thuan Kim Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Oanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Linda Ho
 
Petitioner
Vinh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Chin Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Tang Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Long Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Vi Duc Luu
 
Petitioner
Thanh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ngoc Dung Thi Le
 
Petitioner
Thanh Ba Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Xe Thi Dao
 
Petitioner
Michael Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lan Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Vinh V Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nga Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tai Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Quoc Minh Vo
 
Petitioner
Tieng Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thien Huong Le
 
Petitioner
Tuyen Bang Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuc Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thao PhuongThi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Minh DucHong Vo
 
Petitioner
Tam Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Huong Tran
 
Petitioner
Doi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuong Le Pham
 
Petitioner
Dat Dinh
 
Petitioner
Nguyen, Amy Hang
 
Petitioner
Nhat D. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thim Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Bong Thi Ngo
 
Petitioner
Trang Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Bac Hoai Le
 
Petitioner
Thang V. Tran
 
Petitioner
Nam Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lam Nguyen
 
Petitioner
My Thanh Duong
 
Petitioner
Dong Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Hien Van Luong
 
Petitioner
My Ha Thi Tran
 
Petitioner
Hung H. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuyet Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Kim Thi Chau
 
Petitioner
Le Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dien Xuan Le
 
Petitioner
Van Vo
 
Petitioner
Billy Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Quoc Tuan Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Victoria Hue Vu
 
Petitioner
Dinh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hien KimThi Le
 
Petitioner
Tam V. Le
 
Petitioner
Phuc Du Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Anh Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tina Chau Vu
 
Petitioner
Dat Phat Truong
 
Petitioner
Tieng Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Michael Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hung Van Ha
 
Petitioner
Victor Tran
 
Petitioner
Manh Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Luu Hoa-T Pham
 
Petitioner
Liem Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thao Van Pham
 
Petitioner
Tan Phat Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Chuong Van Vu
 
Petitioner
Dung Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Mai Quynh Pham
 
Petitioner
Kim Tran Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hieu Trung Tran
 
Petitioner
Thomas Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hung Van Pham
 
Petitioner
Bon Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuong NgaThi Vu
 
Petitioner
My Ai Tran
 
Petitioner
Linda Tran
 
Petitioner
Dua V Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thang Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Tien Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hanh Thi Pham
 
Petitioner
Nghia M Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Jennifer Nguyen Penchas
 
Petitioner
Uyen T Dinh
 
Petitioner
Sang Tran
 
Petitioner
Loan Kim Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuong Thi Lyanna
 
Petitioner
Thai Quang Tran
 
Petitioner
Trang Thuy Au
 
Petitioner
Tu Tran
 
Petitioner
Hung Le
 
Petitioner
Phuong Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tai Lam
 
Petitioner
Bao Loc Ho
 
Petitioner
David Dieu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
My Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hien Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Liem Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Steven Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Da Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lien Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Larry Liem Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Micki Khanh Tran
 
Petitioner
An Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lien Van Vo
 
Petitioner
Donald Hanh Tran
 
Petitioner
Khoa Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nang Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Steven Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hong T. Thach
 
Petitioner
Buong Thi Ho
 
Petitioner
Hien Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Luon Danh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Cam H Huynh
 
Petitioner
Khang Trong Bui
 
Petitioner
Hai Tran
 
Petitioner
Linda Tran
 
Petitioner
Minh Pham
 
Petitioner
Khoi Van Vu
 
Petitioner
Linda Thi Phung
 
Petitioner
Tam Hong Tran
 
Petitioner
Van Hong Truong
 
Petitioner
An Ngoc Pham
 
Petitioner
Tuan T. Dang
 
Petitioner
Trang Kim Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hoa T. Le
 
Petitioner
Dinh Ho
 
Petitioner
Billy Binh Duong
 
Petitioner
Nu Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
John Phuc Duong
 
Petitioner
Son Truong Le
 
Petitioner
Bao Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ann Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuong MaiThi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Man Minh Tran
 
Petitioner
Peter Duc Kieu
 
Petitioner
Ha Van Tran
 
Petitioner
John Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Quyen Pham
 
Petitioner
Xinh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hai Van Le
 
Petitioner
Hai Cong Pham
 
Petitioner
Hai Trung Vo
 
Petitioner
Tai Minh Ngo
 
Petitioner
Nam Be Tran
 
Petitioner
Loc Phi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tin Van Ho
 
Petitioner
Paul Phan Pham
 
Petitioner
Thanh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuong Kim Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Minh Dinh Tran
 
Petitioner
Thuy Thi Hoang
 
Petitioner
Khang Thai Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung Hong Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Billy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Khuong Bao Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Oanh Hoang Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuan Anh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thuy LinhThi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Chi Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thin Le
 
Petitioner
Nancy Tran
 
Petitioner
Hai Van Phan
 
Petitioner
Hao Dinh Tran
 
Petitioner
Peter Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
David Ngo
 
Petitioner
Holly H. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hong Bui
 
Petitioner
Mao Quy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Duc V. Pham
 
Petitioner
Nhi Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Viet Anh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Mai Thi Le
 
Petitioner
Sharon Bich Nhu Tran
 
Petitioner
Dong Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Kieu Diem Tran
 
Petitioner
Song Van Vo
 
Petitioner
Dung Anh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
An Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phi-Linh Vu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dong Van Pham
 
Petitioner
Frank Huynh
 
Petitioner
John Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dang Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Son Kim Le
 
Petitioner
Anthony Hoa Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hoang Van
 
Petitioner
Toan T. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Chau Thien Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hoa Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lisa Huong Huynh
 
Petitioner
Tu Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tam M. Phan
 
Petitioner
Duong Minh Le
 
Petitioner
Hoat Vu
 
Petitioner
Kevin Hoang
 
Petitioner
Mai H Tran
 
Petitioner
Nam Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Dao Van Phu
 
Petitioner
Thamnh-Linh Vu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thanh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Joseph Tinh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tam Dinh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nhan T. Tran
 
Petitioner
John Vu
 
Petitioner
Nam Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phuoc Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung Ngoc Huynh
 
Petitioner
Long Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Loan Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tina Hoang
 
Petitioner
Hoan Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thu V. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Bill Quang Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Mike Pham
 
Petitioner
Eric Oanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Duy Quoc Ha
 
Petitioner
Kia Minh Lam
 
Petitioner
Sao Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuyet Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hung Hoa Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Andy Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dau Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Be Chin Thi Huynh
 
Petitioner
Hai Minh Tran
 
Petitioner
Van HuuDuc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuong Vi Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hai Van Pham
 
Petitioner
John Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Khanh Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Thanh Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Thu Trang T Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Jimmy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Cong Huu Phan
 
Petitioner
Henry Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Jackie Lun Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Kim Oanh Thi Ngo
 
Petitioner
Mai Thi Doan
 
Petitioner
Khanh Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Dung Van Lai
 
Petitioner
Hoa Thi Duong
 
Petitioner
Vuong Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hong HoaThi Tran
 
Petitioner
John Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuoi Ngoc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Cuong Van Cao
 
Petitioner
Hanh V Tran
 
Petitioner
Quyen Duc Doan
 
Petitioner
Hien Van Dang
 
Petitioner
Ut T. Chau
 
Petitioner
Thai Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Victoria Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Minh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Gia Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tri Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Binh V. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hoang Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phat Tan Huynh
 
Petitioner
Nga Thi Tran
 
Petitioner
Nghia Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hao Van Ngo
 
Petitioner
Thuy Thi Thu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nancy Bui
 
Petitioner
Thinh T. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tam Thi Pham
 
Petitioner
Minh Van Le
 
Petitioner
Richard Hien Vo
 
Petitioner
Ut Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ba Thu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hang Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dong Viet Vu
 
Petitioner
Laura Trinh
 
Petitioner
Sen Minh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nhat Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ut Thi Le
 
Petitioner
Kim Anh Do
 
Petitioner
Thong Van Trinh
 
Petitioner
Qui Quan Tran
 
Petitioner
Tiffany Vo
 
Petitioner
Luan Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Elaine N. Le
 
Petitioner
Ngoc-Trang Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Khang Quoc Le
 
Petitioner
Luyen Do
 
Petitioner
Thy Phuong T. Le
 
Petitioner
Lien Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Cuong Minh Vo
 
Petitioner
Trung Tran
 
Petitioner
Hong Thanh Bui
 
Petitioner
Dung Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Son Truc Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Anh Duong Huynh
 
Petitioner
Christopher Hoang Tran
 
Petitioner
John Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Johnny V Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Binh V. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dieu Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
He Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Duc Hoai Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lo Van Ngo
 
Petitioner
Trung K Hoang
 
Petitioner
Dung Minh Pham
 
Petitioner
Minh Trang Ngo
 
Petitioner
Lee Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lisa Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hung Tran
 
Petitioner
Nam PhuongThi Do
 
Petitioner
Trang Xuan Dinh
 
Petitioner
Mary T. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Anh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ngan T. Tran
 
Petitioner
Doi Tran
 
Petitioner
Thuong Truong
 
Petitioner
Thi Truong Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ret Thi Ho
 
Petitioner
Michelle Le Tran
 
Petitioner
Mary Ngo
 
Petitioner
Tuyen Minh Hoang
 
Petitioner
Qguuanygen Van Dang
 
Petitioner
Luot Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Vu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Den Tran
 
Petitioner
Tinh Viet Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Duc Van Le
 
Petitioner
Tony Thai Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Trang Mai
 
Petitioner
Oanh Thuc Hoang
 
Petitioner
Melissa T Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Anh Que Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tien Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tuong Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thuan Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Loc Phuoc Duong
 
Petitioner
Hieu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Nam Van Le
 
Petitioner
Lan Thi Vu
 
Petitioner
Hue Tran
 
Petitioner
Linda Thuy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Duyen Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Danny V Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Phu Thanh Le
 
Petitioner
Liep Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Joseph Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Giau Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lucky Thanh Ngo
 
Petitioner
Tham Thi Dinh
 
Petitioner
Duc Huu Nguyen
 
Petitioner
My Ha Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hung Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hoang Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tien Le
 
Petitioner
Sang Thanh Bui
 
Petitioner
Dung Thi Pham
 
Petitioner
Lap Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Vui Le
 
Petitioner
Tommy Thong Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Thuy Le Pham
 
Petitioner
Toan Ba Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Simon H. Le
 
Petitioner
Loan Do Pham
 
Petitioner
Thanh Ngoc Huynh
 
Petitioner
Minh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Qui Thi Dang
 
Petitioner
My Linh T. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Giai Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Trung Thanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Kim Dung T Tran
 
Petitioner
Loan Tuong Pham
 
Petitioner
Khai Pham
 
Petitioner
Co Van Mai
 
Petitioner
Ky Pham
 
Petitioner
Thanh-Huyen Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Dung Thi Doan
 
Petitioner
Toan D. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Hao Thi Vo
 
Petitioner
Nhanh Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Thuy Anh Thi Le
 
Petitioner
Dich Bui
 
Petitioner
Minh Din Dui
 
Petitioner
Cam Thi Lanh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Lan Thi Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Ut V. Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Jimmy Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tony Tang
 
Petitioner
Chi Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Bien Van Tran
 
Petitioner
Dinh Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Quyen Hoang Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Menh Van Nguyen
 
Petitioner
Tru Ngoc Dang
 
Petitioner
Xuan Van Pham
 
Petitioner
Thuong Tran
 
Petitioner
Thanh Minh Hoang
 
Petitioner
Sac Van Vu
 
Petitioner
Hoa Thi Bui
 
Petitioner
Mikal C Watts, et al.
Mr. Francisco Guerra IV
James Rackley
Mr. Travis Carey Headley
Mr. Mark Anthony Fassold
Mr. Fields Alexander
Mr. David J. Beck
Mr. Michael J. Murray
Mr. Mikal C. Watts
Respondent
Robert C. Hilliard, Robert C. Hilliard LLP and Hilliard Munoz Gonzales LLP
Mr. Michael Ernest Richardson II
Mr. Joel Thomas Towner
Mr. Kyle A. Lawrence
Mr. David J. Beck
Mr. Fields Alexander
Mr. Russell S. Post
Respondent
Thim T. Nguyen, et al.
Mr. Lance C. Kassab
Mr. David E. Kassab
Ms. Minh-Tam Tammy Tran
Mr. Kevin H. Dubose
Petitioner
...
...